ASCO 2014: Pick your poison in CRC; pending bigger trials, they all look the same
By Randy Osborne, Staff Writer
CHICAGO – Like the late-stage adjuvant breast cancer study that failed but brought big benefits, a phase III study comparing the four commonest, first-line regimens in metastatic colorectal cancer (CRC) without KRAS mutations may have seemed a letdown at first.
But the trial, one of a handful highlighted during the plenary session of the 50th annual American Society of Clinical Oncology, set a new bar for experiments with drugs targeting the disease, and yielded findings that represent “the tip of the iceberg of what we stand to learn,” said Alan Venook, physician at the University of California-San Francisco, who presented the data.
In the study, median survival was about 29 months, no matter which approach was used: bevacizumab (Avastin, Roche AG) plus chemotherapy or cetuximab (Erbitux, Eli Lilly and Co.) plus chemo. The regimens FOLFOX (oxaliplatin/5-fluorouracil/leucovorin) or FOLFIRI (irinotecan/5-fluorouracil/leucovorin) both turned out acceptable, too.
“We had no knowledge which one would have been better,” said Venook. “This was essentially looking for a difference in the treatment arms.” But the experiment found “no difference between these two therapies [bevacizumab and cetuximab] as a starting point for these patients.”
Enrolling 1,137 patients with untreated metastatic CRC, the study funded by the National Institutes of Health randomly assigned them to get bevacizumab plus chemo or cetuximab plus chemo. Selection of the chemo regimen was based on physician preference, with doctors for 26.6 percent of patients opting for FOLFIRI and 73.4 percent for FOLFOX. The median follow-up was 24 months.
Researchers found no significant differences in either overall survival (OS) or progression-free survival (PFS) between the treatment groups. In the bevacizumab plus chemo arm, OS and PFS totaled 29 months and 10.8 months, respectively. In the cetuximab plus chemo arm, the numbers were 29.9 months and 10.4 months respectively.
No new treatment side effects turned up. The OS of 29 months in both arms sets a “new benchmark” for CRC trials, with 10 percent of patients in the study living beyond five years, Venook said, and “results apply in a variety of practice settings, not just academic settings.” Importantly, the study “clarifies the standard of care” and “answers a question that industry might not ask,” since the answers could go against the interests of drug makers, he said.
The study lasted 10 years, involving 14 amendments and 11 interim analyses,” We took as long as was necessary to get the answer,” Venook said. Some 44,000 biospecimens were collected, yet to be fully analyzed. “We hope that this can inform future studies,” he said.
Meanwhile, what’s a clinician to do, when choosing a regimen in CRC? “Flipping a coin is not optimal,” Venook said, in response to an audience member’s question. “Further molecular analysis may be clearer about identifying patients who are the proper candidates. Expanded RAS analyses might inform us. We’re in the process of doing the analysis and we don’t have those results yet.”
The choice of chemo regimen is “very much market-driven in the U.S. Seventy-five percent of patients will receive FOLFOX, based on habit as much as anything else. I hope this study might raise the possibility of FOLFIRI,” Venook said, though toxicity has most to do with selection. “Cetuximab, frankly, causes a severe skin rash in many patients, and that would be something that should be considered as well.”
Findings of the experiment point to the need for larger trials, which could yield more precision and show plainer differences between treatment choices. “This is very much good to have these options,” Venook said. “As we evolve and get more biomarkers, for example, I hope we’ll be more clear on what the right thing to do is.”
See the next edition of BioWorld Today for more on this story.
Outside of the US
In the U.S. and Canada: +1-800-336-4474
Outside the U.S.: +44-203-684-1796
Hours: Monday - Friday, 8:00am - 6:00 pm EST